MC Arunan | 29 MAR 2011 | filed under : Education

University-Institute Interactions: How will it Improve Undergraduate Biology Training in India?

MC Arunan
Sophia College,
Mumbai

 

There are a few successful individual initiatives in University-Institute interactions in the past, some of them sustained since the eighties. Even as there is scope for institutionalizing these efforts further by involving more such city colleges in the ambit, the reproducibility of this engaging interaction involving research institutes and colleges in other centers in the country, is not in any serious doubt. Rather, it is highly called for, since potential scientists should be tapped at an early age onwards, from the academic hinterlands spread across the country. The Get Involved in Biology Series(GIBS) and the Wikilabs,  initiated at the Homi Bhabha Center for Science Education, TIFR, Mumbai, recently, as well as programs like the Season Watch (NCBS, Bengaluru) are expected to functionally network students, teachers and researchers across the country through engaging in collaborative research in undergraduate biology. Harnessing the potential of the rich biodiversity, by developing newer model systems that are cost-effective and at the same time powerful enough to address even highly sophisticated questions is one of the other objectives.

What are some successful examples? Should they/could they be promoted through specific efforts?
Life science program of the Sophia College (affiliated to Mumbai University) and the DBS (formerly the Molecular Biology Unit) of the TIFR, Mumbai:  From the keen interest taken by Obaid Siddiqi in the eighties to the current support of youngsters like Vidita Vaidya, Shubha Tole, Krishanu Ray and up to most of the lately recruited faculty at the TIFR, there is sustained interactive programs between these two centers. (K. Vijayraghavan, currently Director, NCBS may  recall, the first fly experiment we had conducted at the Sophia College was by using the temperature sensitive paralytic mutants from his lab at the TIFR, when he was a graduate student). Today, if the Life science Department of the Sophia College for Women is known as one of the few centers in the country for teaching Neuroscience through hands-on research, it is because of this synergy. Many more programs including collaborative research programs are planned between these two centers, till date.

As lately as in 2007, the late Veronica Rodrigues wanted a sustained undergraduate research program in Drosophila Functional Genomics involving massive number of students from first year BSc to the final year Master’s program and college teachers. Students called the program Drosofun!
More than 30 students worked together to screen these RNAi fly lines for behavioral defects including that in learning; it could not, however, be continued after two months, as Veronica had to shift to Begaluru, due to  illness.
These person-centered initiatives could be institutionalized by involving more such teachers (& students) of other city colleges too, in programs like what Veronica had in mind. Veronica and some of us were inspired by Utpal Bannerjee’s (UCLA) forays into undergraduate research programs in the US and also by the HHMI initiatives.

How can one harness the collective intellectual resources and facilities in India to provide high quality education in the life sciences for college students?

“Potential scientists should be spawned in schools and colleges/universities; not at doctoral level programs.”(Annals of Neurosciences, 17 (4):152-153, 2010) >>

20,000 colleges and about 1.5 million undergraduate biology students in India give the impression that we have lost out even before we ever started to address the issue. However, some of us feel that these numbers and the problems associated with them will be amenable, if we take a different approach than the conventional one. Interestingly, this number is going to be nearly doubled by 2017 when the next five- year plan concludes, according to one projection by the government. (This is because India is planning to catch up with the enrollment numbers what China has today in higher education - 20% of the age group, by then).

What is the way out? In tapping the 50,000 odd college biology teachers, most of who are teaching at the undergraduate level across the country! That is, if we don’t make it as part of the problem; but it is counted as an asset like how teachers in Sophia college in the eighties of the last century and the undergraduate students in Jaipur are counted as an asset, today. (Jaipur students along with a few junior faculties have their on-line mentors in Mumbai and Bengaluru, to start undergraduate research using fruit fly as the model system. These students in Jaipur are pursuing undergraduate research to understand the biological basis of behavior, including the cognitive behavior.  For the first time, in Jaipur and its neighborhood, one can avail flies through this resource center, run exclusively by undergraduate students. They proudly call their center, the Drosophila Resource Center or DRC, Jaipur!)

In the era of the Internet (though it will yet take time to reach penetration in all colleges in the country, it will reach fast if we make it as part of a national plan), functional networking of 20,000 colleges can be done through launching a Biology Network with real nodal centers, about 500 of them, in the whole country. These nodal centers are notionally catering to 100 teachers each, though its real role is to sort out logistical problems expectedly encountered by them in their place of activity/research. (One major issue will, perhaps, be to trouble-shoot the Internet access facility bottle-necks. A few others will be to sort out organizational behavior issues between the college Principal/Management and the teachers /students. Enrolling more teachers in the catchment area through inspiring programs will be another job requirement of the persons at the nodal center).  Dr M.K. Bhan of the Department of Biotechnology, New Delhi had stated recently about plans to identify 500 colleges for a similar purpose.

Exciting undergraduate research questions in biology in a country as rich and diverse in biodiversity as India will be for the asking. Several initiatives like MigrantWatch/ SeasonWatch (NCBS, Bengaluru) are harbingers of more deep and penetrating questions that can be addressed at least partly at the level of mofussil colleges, with the help of resources available at the Biology Network. Extending these programs or part of such studies through the network is also going to be a natural process, then. Get Involved in Biology Series (GIBS) is a series of research programs initiated recently for which GIBS Awards will be earmarked to promote undergraduate and school biology research. Several other incentives too could be formulated, like giving out participation certificates as is being done in the latest program under the GIBS-I, the Brain & Behavior Public Awareness Program.  

A program called Wikilabs has been initiated recently, at the Homi Bhabha Center for Science Education, TIFR, Mumbai, India.  This is intended to collaboratively conduct research by collecting data, and also collectively analyze, discuss and publish papers in any area of scholarship. As a beginning, students and teachers from school onwards are encouraged to collect data on (a) animals that have multiple locomotor ability e.g.  backwards as well as forward movement (b) common birds that can walk as well as hop and (c) one tree each in the neighborhood to clock its leaf-shedding, sprouting and flowering, round the year (e.g. “the Gulmohur tree in my neighborhood is sprouting leaves; how about yours?”), to be posted on a site developed at http://wiki.metastudio.org for that purpose, under the Get Involved in Biology Series (GIBS). This is closely aligned with the SeasonWatch program initiated recently by the NCBS, Bengaluru. Several active participants will be given GIBS Wikilabs Collaborative Research (WCR) Fellowship in the first week of October each year, coinciding with the announcement of the Nobel prizes.

We seek collaboration of all like-minded individuals and groups to the Get Involved in Biology Series (GIBS).

Dear Sir... I am really impressed by the thought process....

Dear Sir...


I am really impressed by the thought process.... I am sure the group will become bigger and better by each passing day. Undergraduate teachers, possesing talent but lacking facility will be benifited and this increase in knowledge will be passed on to thousands of budding Biologiest of our young country.


I will be peased to do whatever I can for the same.


Thank you so much sir for this brillient initiative.


Regards...


Dr. Sonal Dasani


Department of Life Sciences


K.C. College, Mumbai 

 Dear Dr. Arunan, The idea is good, but how to implement

 Dear Dr. Arunan,

The idea is good, but how to implement it?

Yes, ideas first and actions follows.

We talk a lot on quality and undermine it by our deeds.

A sad present day reality!

Hope it will change or else we have to change it.

A good initiative.

Mycongrats.

I wish to join.

Dr. Shaju Thomas

Dear Shaju,  Your college is most suited to be one of the

Dear Shaju, 

Your college is most suited to be one of the 500 hubs, in that area. If you still do not have an ongoing drosophila culture in your college, let us start one and make it as a mini Drosophila Resource Center (DRC), to cater to the nearby colleges and even schools. DRC will also be equiped with protocols and skilled human resource. With minimum facilities, the active involvement of undergraduate students alone could manage the maintenance of this center. Post Graduate students then may not have to go elsewhere to  do their project work. There are many research sceintists using the Fly as the model system, have already offered help in this collaborative endeavour. Once started, many interesting questions could be addressed in various areas of Biology from cell biology  to immunolgy , cancer, neurodegenerative diseases and cognitive neurosciences, using this system. Integartion of research in the teaching-learning process is what we will achieve at the first stage.

Looking forward to be a part of the Collaborative Undergraduate Biology Research (CUB Research) program.

M.C.Arunan

Visiting Scientist, 

Homi Bhabha Center for Science Education, TIFR,

Mumbai- 400 088, India

Strengthening Undergraduate Education and Research are very

Strengthening Undergraduate Education and Research are very important, and I congragulate all scientists and teachers for their strong efforts!!  

But what about the quality of PhD 's and MSc students passing out right now??

Many are outsourcing thesis and Lab work because they lack good Labs/guides in their own Institute. Many guides also find this an easy way of registering several PhD students under their names. Some students do a good job by working at other faciltites and Labs. Others do very little work--and get data form some outside source which is not accountable to anyone!  So, how does UGC allow this to continue.

Frightening thought: Many of these PhD's will be future senior scientists and mentors for the next generation!

So, are there any ideas on how we can improve this situation??

 

Dr.VN Sumantran

Adjunct Prof. Dept Biotechnology

IIT-Madras

 

The sharing of your knowledge and experiance with community

The sharing of your knowledge and experiance with community is nice .what we want is the innovative idea and  their supporters like you.The innovative ideas should be promoted and failure should not be punished.We required Those individaus who can see like evryone else but think like nobody can in a positiv way .Elitism have to avoided then we can prepare a better platform to develop indian science to world level.

Devendra Meena

National Overseas Fellow,(Govt. of India)

Center for Bioscience

School of Basic and Applied Science

Central University of Punjab,

Bathinda-151001

Dear Arunan, These are great efforts to get undergraduate

Dear Arunan,

These are great efforts to get undergraduate students hooked onto the scientific process early on. The message should be spread about these initiatives so that more and more college and research faculty across the country could get involved.
Would love to part of such efforts once I am back in India.

Pravin A Nair,
Research Associate,
Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center,
New York, New York.

Dear sir, This type of efforts will provide more

Dear sir,
This type of efforts will provide more platform for an undergraduate student to be more familiar with the Research Running all around the world By just Linking himself to a infinite source of Knowledge. I feel very proud to be an initiative stone for this building block.

Congratulations!

Neeraj Upadhyay
B.Tech-M.Tech Dual degree
IXth Semester Student
CCT Department, Rajasthan University,
Jaipur

It's great pleasure for an undergraduate to have an

It's great pleasure for an undergraduate to have an initiation program like this.Congratulations !! sir ,This is very good project and need to be accelerated.It's now our responsibility to give this venture a new shape with a well defined goal.The main thing is understanding the idea and make others to understand."So now let us shake the slept Academic staff and young talents to built this idea into a best shape"

Regards
Himanshu Joshi
M.Tech Student
Cognitive Neuroscience Division
Centre for converging Technologies
Jaipur Rajasthan

Dear Sir, It feels great to read this article and get a

Dear Sir,

It feels great to read this article and get a closer view of how we can improve undergraduate biology training in India and what steps need to be taken in this direction.Thank you so much for sharing all these facts & ideas about the related research and study undergoing in various institutions across India.
A big welcome to Wikilabs!!!

Best Wishes,
Nidhi Sharma
CCT,Jaipur.

Dear Nidhi, The WikiLabs in its pilot scale started in CCT

Dear Nidhi,
The WikiLabs in its pilot scale started in CCT Jaipur , an year ago, with the fly group there collaborating with the Mumbai group. We wish your batch will carry on the fly larval learning and memory studies that was initiated by your seniors at the Center for Converging Technologies, in collaboration with people elsewhere.

Dear sir, It feels great to be a part of such an

Dear sir,
It feels great to be a part of such an initiative.
We'll try to learn from all the hard work done by our seniors and come up with some commendable work from DRC in future.
Looking forward for support and guidance from you along with our seniors.

thanks,

Dear Arunan, GIBS indeed is a good initiative. and though

Dear Arunan,

GIBS indeed is a good initiative. and though the project themes may appear simple, however it requires meticulous approach and aims at improving the observation as well as analytical skills of the students and the teachers. Instead of doing isolated experiments, its always useful to do a series of them, directed towards specific objectives.

I am sure such enthusiasm and vision will transform the way biology is taught at the undergraduate level across the country!

Best Wishes,
Urmi Bajpai,
Deptt of Biomedical Sciences, ANDC

Dear Urmi, I was going through your piece on experiments in

Dear Urmi,
I was going through your piece on experiments in undergraduate research carried out at the AND college. It is remarkable, indeed. We need more of such collaborations between research institutes and colleges; not only in the cities but in far-flung areas. In fact, such attempts have to be institutionalized.

Currently, some of us are involved in working group meetings towards the 12th Plan 2012-2017. I will be interested to get more information about the undergraduate research going on currently at AND as part of the OSDD or otherwise. I will also be glad to receive information on similar schemes in other colleges, if any. I am confident that the involvement of the faculty in this collaborative undergraduate research will be the right way to empower teachers in colleges who otherwise are a deprived lot: deprived of even elementary research facilities including scientific literature.The worst sense of deprivation for them is the sense of isolation from active science. That is what is sought to be removed by this scheme.

Perhaps, we need to introduce students to the excitement of scientific research early on,from school itself. Many research questions can be addressed without the need of highly equipped laboratories, though needless to say such laboratories help immensely. Get Involved in Biology Series initiated at the HBCSE,TIFR look forward to collaboration with people like you to promote the spirit of scientific research across the country.

This, perhaps, will be one of the ways to attract students (and parents) to basic science programs.

M.C.Arunan

Congratulations!

It is great to read about this uprising in science and tapping young talent at the undergraduate level. I am proud to be a part of the Get in involved in Biology Series. Congratulations to Dr.Arunan and his team at HBCSE, Sophia College for Women and all those who have kept the spirit of science education burning amidst all difficulties!

Post new comment

  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Use to create page breaks.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
Image CAPTCHA
Enter the characters shown in the image.

Bookmark and Share